Saturday, March 31, 2018

Jim Aparo Original Art Sales Trends - Part 1: The Phantom

Jim Aparo original art featuring Charlton character The Phantom
Jim Aparo art from The Phantom #38 sold through Heritage Auctions

Jim Aparo original art featuring The Phantom

This is a blog about Original Comic Art Trends with data analysis based on past sales for legendary artist Jim Aparo. Part 1 focuses on Aparo's Charlton art with emphasis on The Phantom.  Other Charlton art by Aparo sold during the same period will be mentioned for context but not analyzed.

The lots sold included individual splash and interior pages, multi page lots, and even two complete stories.  There were no covers by Jim Aparo sold through Heritage Auctions for The Phantom comics during the analysis period.

On a personal note, Jim Aparo was one of my favorite artists as a young reader in the late seventies.  I treasured most Aparo's art during his long run on The Brave and the Bold.  While The Phantom was not a character I personally followed, the early Charlton work by Aparo is a good place to begin this blog.

Quick Data Summary

  • 78 unique pages
  • 43 lots
  • Two complete stories
  • Sold through Heritage Auctions from May 2009 to November 2017
  • Minimum price: 103.57 (Average price of a 3 page lot)
  • Maximum price:  896.25 (two page splash)
Let's start with some definitions and a few obvious observations:
interior art - any pages of art excluding the cover, typically separated into panels
splash page - special class of interior art that typically only has one or very few panels
two page splash (spread) - two pages of art joined together to form one picture (may or may not be a single panel
title page - contains the title, often a splash page, traditionally the first page of the story

For purposes of my analysis, I have categorized the various pages of art in groups such as cover, splash, and interior pages.  I  have further subdivided splash and interior pages since not all are created equal in terms of their visual appeal.  The data demonstrates the obvious observation that a splash page is generally higher valued than a typical interior page, and the cover is valued more than an interior splash page.  It is also intuitive that pages prominently featuring the title hero fetch higher prices than those that do not.

Interior art from The Phantom #32
Interior art from The Phantom #32
The first picture is an example of interior art with every panel featuring the main hero.  The number of panels featuring the hero, type of action, and drama in the story can all influence the interest of a page.

The next three pages illustrate art with no panels of the featured character or even a colorful villain.  While the art has amazing detail, the three pages were sold as a lot with two other pages since as individual pages they likely would not have sold well.
Interior art from The Phantom #38
Interior art from The Phantom #38


In May 2012, Page 16 from Phantom #32 brought in a whopping $787.51.  Though a title page strongly featuring The Phantom, the page is still an interior page with three panels, so it would be hard to describe it as a splash page.  Page 16 impacted the scatter plot and calculation of correlation between price and the passage of time, but there were many pages that did not suggest that prices were simply going up during the nine year duration of the Phantom art sales.


Jim Aparo penciled other works for Charlton including the The Many Ghosts of Dr. Graves.  This interior page is the title page and is interesting for the names of the contributors, Steve Skeates and Dick Giordano along with Aparo, all who went on to do work at DC.



Legal: The author does not currently own any original artwork by Jim Aparo. Please review web version sidebar for disclaimer information.  
Copyright 2018 Patrick Bain